FAQ: Click here to learn more about WhoDunnit
and our interactive
Murder Mystery Dinner Theater productions.


Sponsor a WhoDunnit show and reap the benefits!

Special thanks to this year's Sponsors

Click here to learn more about becoming a WhoDunnit sponsor

Click Here To Support WhoDunnit via giveforgoodlouisville.org

Check Out Next Season!

Presenting original, interactive murder mysteries to delight
and entertain!

Doors open at 6:30; show starts at 7:00. Price includes dinner, show, tax and gratuity. A cash bar is available.

WhoDunnit shows are original, lively and thoroughly entertaining, as well as a mystery lover's dream! Clues are cleverly included in the scripted action, and in between scenes (as the audience enjoys a fine meal) the actors mingle with the audience in character, allowing guests to ask questions and get more clues. If you ask them if they are the killer, they will all say no, but that is the only time they are permitted to lie. To all other questions, they must either evade the question or tell you the truth. Audiences love interacting with the characters and trying to figure out who dunnit!


NOTICE: The WhoDunnit logo is a registered trademark of WhoDunnit Inc., and is protected by U.S. and international law.


WhoDunnit is a 501(c)(3) non-profit, donation-supported corporation for the performing arts.



Full Member: Louisville Independent Business Association
Center for Non-Profit Excellence




Saturday Evenings, Sept. 16–Oct. 28

Murder by Quarry: The Case of the Murderous Masterpiece

by A. S. Waterman

Link to purchase tickets

directed by Erica Goldsmith

assistant directed by Heather Hensley

Step back in time to 1908, the era of the greatest mystery stories ever told! Who killed the evil duke Harry Hollingsworth, and why? Are others in danger? And how does La Curèe, the mysterious masterpiece of art, come into play? Match wits with WhoDunnit’s favorite detective Dr. Angus MacCrimmon, as he returns to solve his newest, most challenging and most intriguing mystery ever!

The menu for this New England based mystery features 4 food dishes of the region and beverages to be purchased separately that complements the food.

NOTE! On OCTOBER 28th there will be a limit to three menu choices. Duchess Hollingsworth's Shirmp and Scallop Basilicato will not be available. In order for this dish to be at it's best, it is made to order. Duchess Hollingsworth is hosting multiple parties on that night and her staff is over taxed and can't possibly do the Basilicato justice. Our apologies.

  1. MacCrimmon's New England Boiled Dinner. A plot twist on the classic. Pot roast plated with potatoes and mixed vegetables.
  2. Duchess Hollingsworth's Shrimp and Scallop Basilicato. A dish worthy of high society Newport. Garlic butter sautéed shrimp,and natural sea scallops served with linguine tossed in a white wine and basil pesto sauce. Succulent.
  3. Chicken Oscar WhoDunnit? Seared chicken breast topped with crab imperial, asparagus and hollandaise sauce. Served over a bed of gourmet rice. Any good detective can solve this delightful dilemma!
  4. Murder by Quarry (Chicken Penne Santorini). Whole wheat penne pasta tossed with chicken, mushrooms, spinach, olives, sun-dried tomatoes, garlic and feta cheese in a white wine, olive and pesto sauce. Note, the less-murderous version, no chickens harmed, is also available for our vegetarians delight.

Dessert: The Duke of Mere's Angel food cake served with strawberries and whipped cream.

Libations (purchased separately/not included in the ticket price but Oh so murderously divine) Boston Rum Punch-2 oz. Traditional Jamaican Rum. Lemonade. Nutmeg or half a strawberry. Orange slice.

The Ward Eight. A New England twist on the Whiskey Sour! The Ward 8 is a cocktail originating in 1898 in Boston, Massachusetts at the bar of the Gilded Age restaurant . 2 ounces rye whiskey. 1/2 ounce fresh lemon juice. 1/2 ounce fresh orange juice. 1 teaspoon grenadine. Maraschino cherry (optional)

Link to purchase tickets

All shows are at The Bristol Bar and Grille, 614 West Main Street, Louisville, KY

Bristol Bar and Grille Logo

The cast includes:

Francis Whitaker returning by popular demand as Dr. Angus MacCrimmon

Heather Hensley as Henrietta Hollingsworth

John Campbell Finnegan as Count Alexei Federov

Ben Rogers as Carlton Royce

Megg Ward as Elyse Beaumont

Sarah Mackell as Hetty Hollingsworth

For reservations call (502) 538-4100


Validated parking available if patrons park in the garage directly behind the Bristol. Entrance to the garage is located on the right side of 6th Street between Main Street and Market Street.

Seating at 6:30 / Show starts at 7:00


Tickets are $48 each for 1-5 guests at a private table. Discounted tickets are for 6 or more guests in a party. This price includes meal, show, tax and gratuity.

Reserve early for parties, groups & corporate functions!
(502) 538-4100


Friday evening, Dec. 15 is sold out at the Bristol.

Still accepting bookings for an additional private party on that date or other dates in December.

Public shows are every Saturday evening, Nov.18–Dec. 23 plus Jan. 5 & 6
Oh! Deadly Night!

Eventbrite Ticket Site

directed by Robert Thompson

assistant directed by Megg Ward

Enter the dark recesses of the underground for a most unusual Christmas celebration. Louisville history and legend come to life in this new holiday twist on some of the city’s most famous ghost stories.


Text and artwork are copyright © 2003 and 2017 WhoDunnit Inc. 2017 Season Show Artwork by Heather Hensley & John Finnegan. Brochure design by Joey Goldsmith. All rights reserved. WhoDunnit Logo designs by A.S. Waterman. Schedule subject to change.


If you don't see our logo, it's not WhoDunnit! ™


WhoDunnit is a 501(c)(3) tax-exempt, non-profit, donation-supported
corporation for the performing arts.